Although “The Star-Spangled Banner” is performed before every
baseball game and at many other public events, it’s notoriously
hard to sing. But in its history, the song has allowed the
performers who can sing it to create memorable and unique
interpretations of the United States’ most prominent musical
symbol.
When “The Star-Spangled Banner” became the national anthem in
1931, the New York Herald Tribune famously described it as
“words that nobody can remember to a tune nobody can sing.” Its
melody is adapted from an 18th-century drinking song, and its
lyrics from a poem that Francis Scott Key wrote 200 years ago
(describing a battle in the War of 1812). And it’s fiendishly hard
to hit all the notes — the highest is an octave and a half above
the lowest.
A 2004 poll found that only 39 percent of Americans could
correctly complete the song’s third line.
Franklin Bruno, songwriter and author of a forthcoming history
of songwriting, The Inside of the Tune, points out that
the anthem anticipated the country’s musical future in the way the
rhythm and rhyme scheme of each verse’s third couplet (“And the
rockets’ red glare, the bombs bursting in air …”) change the song’s
tone by softening the martial quality of the other lines.
“It’s fitting that our national anthem wouldn’t be in
quite the strict English ballad form,” Bruno said.
The national anthem’s symbolic weight also means that when it is
performed in anything but a straightforward way, listeners ascribe
meaning to the deviation. On July 4, 1941, against the backdrop of
World War II, composer Igor Stravinsky premiered an orchestral
arrangement of the anthem that incorporated a few unusual
harmonies. That performance led to a brief skirmish between
Stravinsky and Boston police, who thought he’d violated a state law
against “tampering” with the national anthem.
During the 1968 Major League Baseball World Series, Puerto Rican
singer José Feliciano performed “The Star-Spangled Banner” in the
style of a contemporary folk-pop song, accompanied by acoustic
guitar. It caused a flurry of controversy: “Some people wanted me
deported,” he later said, “as if you can be deported to Puerto
Rico.” (Puerto Rico is a territory of the United States.) But
Feliciano’s version became a minor hit single, and he said that by
the time he reprised his version at a 2012 championship baseball
game, it was generally understood by the audience as “an anthem of
gratitude to a country that had given me a chance.”
Marvin Gaye’s slow, spectral, gospel-tinged rendition performed
at the 1983 National Basketball Association All-Star game,
accompanied by a drum machine, made the song sound shockingly
modern. Former Los Angeles Lakers star Earvin “Magic” Johnson said
Gaye’s performance gave him a feeling of “pride at being an
American ... you almost cried, it was so devastating.”
While singing “The Star-Spangled Banner” is most often a
statement of national pride, it can also be a vehicle for political
protest. A 2006 Spanish-language recording of the song (as “Nuestro
Himno”) criticized American immigration policy.
Jimi Hendrix famously performed his rendition of the anthem at
the 1969 Woodstock music festival as a protest against the Vietnam
War. Complete with “bombing” sound effects, it is the best-known
radical reworking of the anthem. “It’s not unorthodox,” Hendrix
told television interviewer Dick Cavett in September 1969 about his
interpretation of the anthem. “I thought it was beautiful.”
At the time of the 1991 Super Bowl, when Whitney Houston sang
“The Star-Spangled Banner” — with a flourish on the high note of
“land of the free” that propelled it even higher — America was in
the middle of the Gulf War, and she dedicated her performance to
the country’s military. It became a hit when it was released as a
single a few weeks later. It was even more successful when it was
re-released a decade later, with proceeds to benefit New York
firefighters and police after the September 11, 2001, attacks.
Beyoncé Knowles’ recent performances of the anthem (at Barack
Obama’s 2013 inauguration, among other venues) have loosely
followed Houston’s template, including its extra-high note.
That the anthem is hard to sing may be apt; Americans enjoy
freedoms that have not come easily. Over time, “The Star-Spangled
Banner” has become a song that invites expressions of individuality
and of unity. There’s something fitting about that, too.