加载中…
个人资料
  • 博客等级:
  • 博客积分:
  • 博客访问:
  • 关注人气:
  • 获赠金笔:0支
  • 赠出金笔:0支
  • 荣誉徽章:
正文 字体大小:

Unnecessary.Sophistry(21.10%.Is.Also.Okay)

(2024-08-29 15:06:31)
分类: 医学通论.医学绝不是诡辩
Unnecessary Sophistry
( 21. 10% Is Also Okay )




In fact, the guys who always want to ruin TCM
( Traditional Chinese Medicine ) can no longer 
find any reasons for their purpose.

Faced with a large number of facts that TCM 
can effectively treat diseases, those guys 
eitherdo not want to see su ch objective facts, 
do not understand or even pretend not to 
understand all of such objective facts. 

Therefore, they simply deny all of such 
objective facts uniformly or play some tricks 
in theory.


For example, one guy recently said:

"Only 10% of TCM is essence, 
and the rest is dross."


Actually, this is just nonsense!


In fact, no one knows how he got this 10%, 
it's probably just the result  fabricated 
randomly by himself !

Or, the reason for the emergence of  10% 
may also be that he has two concerns:


The first concern is that if he gives a rate 
below 10% , he is afraid of being ridiculed 
by a large amount of facts.

The second concern is that if he gives a 
rate higher than 10%he will be scolded 
by all the guys who  always want  to ruin 
TCM.


It can be seen that he is indeed very pitiful.


Objectively speaking, the development of 
all disciplines has the process of 
absorbing essence and eliminating dross. 

There is no exception in TCM, western 
medicine, or other sciences. 


And the elimination ratio is also more or 
less, there is no standard, and no one 
can specify it in advance.



For example, the bloodletting therapy used 
by western medicine on Mr. Washington in 
1799 is no longer used today, although 
western medicine at the time believed that 
bloodletting therapy was very effective.

Some traditional Chinese medicine treatment 
methods have also been eliminated.

In fact, all of these are the natural ecology 
of disciplinary development, and there is 
no need to make a fuss about them.


This is something like human growth:

No one needs to laugh at the history 
of others wetting the bed, as if he has 
never wet the bed himself !


Even if the essence of TCM is only 10%, it 
does not necessarily mean that TCM must 
be eliminated.

If someone says that 10% is too low, it would 
be enough to ruin TCM, he is actually quite 
ridiculous !


In history, there had been many things in  
western medicine, and not all of them have 
been preserved, the elimination rate of 
western medicine is also very high.

If you don't believe it, you can search for 
"Obsolete western medicine techniques
or  "Obsolete western medicine" on the 
internet, you will understand it at once. 

There's no need for me to list them one by
one. 

In fact, I don't want to discuss such historical 
garbages either.


More over, if we were to eliminate all things 
with an effective utilization rate below 10% 
according to this guy's 10% standard, the 
result would be very ridiculous.

Let's consider the problem from a different 
perspective.

When a person grows up from infancy to 
the age of 20, his weight is generally less 
than 75 kg, but at this time, the accumulated 
food he has consumed often exceeds 7300 kg.

If we only consider from a biological 
perspective, when a person reaches the 
age of 20, his effective utilization rate of 
food is only slightly higher than 1%.

If according to this guy's requirement, the 
effective utilization rate of food must be 
higher than 10%, then both a 20-year-old 
boy and a 20-year-old girl should weigh 
over 730 kilograms ! 

What a huge creature !


Considering that he may be over 70 years old, 
even if his weight once reached 100 kg, he has 
already consumed more than 25000 kg of food 
at this time.

At this point, if we only consider from a biological perspective, his effective utilization rate of food
is only slightly higher than 0.4%.

If according to this guy's requirements, the 
effective utilization rate of food must exceed 
10%, then a person's weight at the age of 70 
should exceed 2500 Kg ! 

Isn't this a joke ?

From this, it can be seen that the so-called 10% 
is just his casual nonsense !

And the biggest problem with such a nonsense 
as he said is:

Maliciously fabricating correct nonsense to 
lure others into thinking incorrectly !

At the same time, we should also recognize that 
the characteristics of such a correct nonsense 
are:

Such a correct nonsense sounds reasonable 
but actually meaningless !

The current issue is:

There is always some guys who are anti-TCM 
addicts.

They often use such correct nonsenses  to 
deceive patients, which is extremely 
despicable !

So, strict precautions must be taken !



0

阅读 收藏 喜欢 打印举报/Report
  

新浪BLOG意见反馈留言板 欢迎批评指正

新浪简介 | About Sina | 广告服务 | 联系我们 | 招聘信息 | 网站律师 | SINA English | 产品答疑

新浪公司 版权所有