加载中…
个人资料
  • 博客等级:
  • 博客积分:
  • 博客访问:
  • 关注人气:
  • 获赠金笔:0支
  • 赠出金笔:0支
  • 荣誉徽章:
正文 字体大小:

另眼看谷歌 -- 懦夫

(2010-03-30 10:52:07)
标签:

杂谈

    昨天半夜匆匆忙忙把专栏写完,痛恨自己为何总是等到最后一分钟才写,虽然有想法,但确实累了一天,快睡着了,没有了兴奋感。

   而且觉得说得有点过分,很有被枪毙的感觉,也很有给评论部同事找麻烦的感觉。

   当局猛烈抨击谷歌,一片附和声,而我却发出不和谐的声音。当然我也不是没有掩饰,也不是淋漓尽致说得那么爽。但就像 Orville Schell 说的那样,CD看得出一直在尝试 push the line,我觉得自己的尝试又一次成功了,希望不要给北京的编辑增加太多麻烦。

   其实我也没说啥疯话。只不过在自我审查的环境中生存太长,都有些神经质的敏感,神经质的变态了......

   今天傍晚,和一个朋友在时代广场HB Brewery一起喝酒聊天,看到网站上出现了自己的文章,终于生存下来,一震兴奋....... 确实应该举杯庆祝.....那个microbrewery的啤酒确实非常非常好。一直在必经之路上,终于不仅尝了一下,而且痛饮了几杯......


In quitting, Google misses its chance



If you want to help change China for the better, you should involve China and be there. Otherwise you won't have an impact on the country simply by claiming a high moral ground and distancing yourself from the place.

That's what I told Nieman curator Bob Giles several years ago when the prestigious journalism foundation decided to withdraw from a program to train Chinese government officials in handling the international media coming to cover the 2008 Beijing Olympics. That decision had left the Fairbank Center for East Asian Research at Harvard University alone for the weeklong sessions.

Giles, in his reply, said he did see the value in these types of training sessions. However the overwhelming protests from Nieman alumni gave him little choice.

It is unsure how many Chinese have heard of Nieman but what is apparent is that Nieman limited its own influence in China by dropping out of that program.

The recent announcement to leave China by Google and GoDaddy, an Internet domain registrar and web-hosting company, citing government censorship as the main reason, struck similarities with the Nieman retreat years ago, though the Google act is of a much bigger scale.

Google, Yahoo and other search engines have played a significant role in China's social transformation in the last decade simply by being in the country and making themselves available to the average Chinese. The impact on the people, society and politics from the fast developing Internet service should never be underestimated.

The progress has been achieved under a system that Google and GoDaddy said is underscored by censorship or self-censorship.

While some view Google's decision as courageous, some regard it as cowardly. Calling it quits is simply not the right attitude, given whatever hardship Google has encountered in operating in China. It is also not the spirit of the Silicon Valley, whose successful businesses often thrive after numerous failures.

For Chinese who google on a daily basis at home and at work, the departure of Google could well mean an inconvenient change in the access to information they are so used to. And since Google is such a powerful search engine and getting more powerful every passing day, some of its functions may not be replaced by its rivals, such as Baidu, which enjoys a much larger share than Google in the China market.

In this sense, the departure of Google has served as a barrier, rather than an aid, to the access to information for many Chinese.

Throughout much of the world, the Internet has contributed to the gradual openness of societies. Withdrawal of Google from China will only serve the opposite effect.

Although China's great social and economic transformation was chiefly engineered by Deng Xiaoping, it would be totally different without the participation of the rest of the world, such as having professors, students, manufacturers, tourists, books and movies from other countries coming to China for the last three decades.

The United States, for example, had very little impact on Cuba by banning its people from traveling to the island nation only 151 km away, and by enforcing an embargo on the country for some 50 years. That's the failure of someone who likes to claim self-righteousness.

If frustration justifies quitting, then many people, who find their ideals clashing with reality, should retire today.

Leaving China is an easy decision for Google to make. Staying on is a much tougher one. It would have enabled Google to have a more positive impact on the huge population in the long run.

 

 

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/08image_e/article_comments.jpg-- 懦夫" TITLE="另眼看谷歌 -- 懦夫" />

0

阅读 收藏 喜欢 打印举报/Report
前一篇:被强奸的感觉
后一篇:Soho的酒屋
  

新浪BLOG意见反馈留言板 欢迎批评指正

新浪简介 | About Sina | 广告服务 | 联系我们 | 招聘信息 | 网站律师 | SINA English | 产品答疑

新浪公司 版权所有