26.Actual.Therapeutic.Effect,More.Important.Than.Logical.Consistency
(2025-10-30 15:33:14)| 分类: 医学通论.医学绝不是诡辩 |
Medical Science Is Never Sophistry
( 26.
Actual Therapeutic
Effect,
More Important
Than
Logical
Consistency )
As all of
us know, TCM ( Traditional
Chinese
Medicine
) can effectively treat
many diseases,
as
evidenced by numerous objective
facts,
and it
is continuously promoted on
television.
However,
what's strange is that some
guys
always
want to ruin TCM simply because
they
cannot
understand anything about TCM.
For a
long time, those guys have disregarded
the
suffering
and helplessness of countless
similar
patients,
constantly indulging in slandering
TCM,
and even
regard slandering TCM as their own skills.
After
long-term blind thinking, those guys
have
indeed
mastered some tricks, one of which
often
makes
them so proud that they can never extricate
themselves from it, that is
the so-called logical
consistency.
In fact,
we do often hear the very
consistent
logical
trap they have woven.
For
example, when a patient is sent to
the
hospital
for treatment, we may hear
something
like the
following logical trap :
1. When
the patient has been treated with
TCM,
if the
patient gets effective treatment at
this
time,
those guys may say that it's okay if
not
treated
and the patient may heal on his own.
But if
the treatment is ineffective, those
guys
may
become abnormally excited and
keep
complaining that TCM is delaying the
treatment,
and thay
may say that if they themselves
were
to treat
it, it would never be ineffective !
2. But
when the patient has been treated
by
Western
medicine, if it is an effective
treatment
at this
time, those guys may say
for
treatment, otherwise it would
have been
too late
to save ."
However,
if the
treatment is ineffective,
those
guys may
say
"
We have done our best,
it would
have
been
better if the patient had been
sent
here for
treatment earlier.”
,
If you
occasionally hear such remarks,
it's
not a big deal.
But if
you frequently hear such remarks,
you
should
take note:
Because
this logically consistent argument
is
essentially a form of sophistry, meaning
that
under any
circumstances, no matter what
the
outcome
after treatment, this sophistry
can
provide
those guys with a seemingly
reasonable
excuse to
justify their own actions or to
belittle
TCM's
treatment, while making it
impossible
for
others to refute any more.
In fact,
this kind of scammer logic is
really
extremely harmful
because it possesses
the
following three
characteristics:
3.1 The only concern of this
scammer logic
is
whether the patient has been treated
by
TCM or
Western medicine, rather than
the
primary
issue that medical science
should
be
concerned with, which is the
treatment
effect.
3.2. This kind of
scammer logic
is
consistent in
form and has the
characteristic of
content independence
This kind
of scammer logic only needs
to reason based
on whether it is treated
with TCM
or Western
medicine.
If it is
treated with TCM, then those
guys
use some words to belittle
TCM's treatment.
But if it
is treated with Western
medicine,
then they use the other words
to praise
Western medicine
treatment
This kind
of scammer logic ensures
that
their reasoning
is 100% independent of
the
condition, treatment, efficacy or
time.
From
this, it can be seen that this kind
of
scammer logic is indeed a
bottomless trap,
where any
content can be loaded into
it,
and there
is also universality in form.
At the
same time, it can ensure that
the
conclusions drawn from this
scammer logic
always
meet the conclusions
predetermined
by those
guys, which can both belittle
TCM
and boast
themselves!
3.3
Logical self consistency
This kind
of scammer logic can
achieve
logical
consistency in form, which
makes
those
guys appear knowledgeable and
logical.
Even if
someone else feels confused,
he
may feel
unable to refute it.
But in
fact, this is the malicious usage
of
logical
reasoning !
Moreover,
this type of scammer logic is
indeed
being
abused now and then or here and there.
So, as
patients or potential patients, we
must
learn to
promptly and quickly identify
this
kind of scammer logic.
If we
truly master the skills to
identify
this scammer logic
in a timely and rapid
manner, then
we have implanted "logic
antibodies specifically
designed to
recognize
scams" into
our own cognitive
system.
And once
we implant such specialized
logic
antibodies for identifying scams into
our
cognitive
system, we can ensure that we
can
quickly
identify all scams from now on.
As matter
of fact, it is very simple to
identify such
scams as long as all of
us keep
a close eye on both
objective
facts
and actual therapeutic
effects.
If some
guy insists on denying a
large
number of
objective facts regardless of
the
actual therapeutic effect
contained
in these
objective facts, then we need
to be
very careful because this
guy may
be a
professional fraudster .
So, if we
remain numb to this kind of
scammer
logic for
a long time, and even think that
this
scammer
logic is reasonable, then those
guys
can
completely destroy our TCM even only
by
this kind
of scammer logic and they even
have
no sense
of guilt at all !
In fact,
TCM can effectively treat
many
diseases, which
has been proven by a
large
number of objective
facts.
Moreover,
such objective facts continue
to emerge, and such
objective facts are
constantly introduced
on television.
Even if
some people cannot understand
such
objective
facts, it is normal.
But it is
only proves that their lack
of
understanding actually means
their
own
cognition is very poor, that's
all !
In order
to eliminate the harm of this
kind of
poor cognition,
it is necessary
to
firmly oppose the transformation
of
cognitive limitation of one guy
person
into the cognitive limitations
of everyone,
or even into professional
standards !
Besides,
since those guys are
particularly
skillful at
playing games such as logical
consistency, they
may know something
about
British philosopher
Wittgenstein
very
well .
Mr.
Wittgenstein had long said that
one
must remain silent about
things that
cannot
be clearly stated.
Of
course, what Mr. Wittgenstein meant
by
silence
is by no means an
unconditional
denial of
many objective facts that are
temporarily incomprehensible,
otherwise
our human
being would only remain
silently in
a state of ignorance forever.
Obviously, the original intention
of
Wittgenstein's statement
of keeping
silent
is
To provide
objective descriptions
of
objective facts that are
temporarily
incomprehensible, in order
to
anticipate more research
in the future.
At the
same time, for any objective
fact
that is
currently unclear, we should
never
completely deny it
!
In
fact, only objectively
describing
all
the original objective
facts ,that
are
currently unclearis , is
our
true respect
for objective facts,
professional spirit
and professional
mission.
If one
completely denies any objective
fact
that he
himself cannot comprehend, it
has
nothing
to do with professional
cognition,
academia
or logic, because any fool
can
completely deny anything he
himself
cannot
comprehend !
In fact,
when discussing medical issues,
we
should
adhere to the core principles
of
medical science, which are
based on facts,
guided by therapeutic
effects,
patient-centered and duty
oriented
in
treating diseases.
And if
someone like them deliberately
uses
professional terminologies to weave
scammer
logic,
and even claims it to be
"logical
consistency" in an attempt to
deceive patients
for a
long time, he is truly lacking
in
professional spirit
!
Because
this kind of scammer logic is
essentially a desecration of
objective
facts,
actual therapeutic effects,
logic
and
medical science !
From the
above analysis, it can be
seen
that
logic is indeed a very
important
discipline, but logic is only a kind
of
knowledge.
Like
other scientific knowledge, it
has
its own
instrumental features.
That is,
as a discipline, logic can
only
play a
positive role when applied
correctly, rationally
and in good
faith
If some
guy uses knowledge of logic
to
specifically construct logical traps
that
are
logically consistent in form,
specifically
for
professional mutual
attacks, then
such
logical
consistency is only a tool for
professional professional
mutual attacks.
As a tool
for professional professional
mutual
attacks, such logical
consistency
has great
deception and destructive
power,
and must
be highly vigilant.
In short,
regarding medical science, as
patients
or potential patients, we
only
need to
be interested in both
objective
facts and
actual therapeutic effects,
while
we should
not blindly believe in word
games
such as logical consistency,
because
not everyone has enough
ability
to timely
identify scams masked by
logical
consistency !
Besides,
for us patients or potential patients,
the actual therapeutic
effect
is far more important
than
logical consistency
!
( ------ Written on July 2, 2025
)

加载中…