加载中…
个人资料
  • 博客等级:
  • 博客积分:
  • 博客访问:
  • 关注人气:
  • 获赠金笔:0支
  • 赠出金笔:0支
  • 荣誉徽章:
正文 字体大小:

26.Actual.Therapeutic.Effect,More.Important.Than.Logical.Consistency

(2025-10-30 15:33:14)
分类: 医学通论.医学绝不是诡辩
  

Medical Science Is Never Sophistry

 

26. Actual Therapeutic Effect, 
More Important Than 
Logical Consistency )





As all of us know, TCM ( Traditional Chinese 
Medicine ) can effectively treat many diseases,
as evidenced by numerous objective facts, 
and it is continuously promoted on television.

However, what's strange is that some guys 
always want to ruin TCM simply because they
cannot understand anything about TCM. 

For a long time, those guys have disregarded the 
suffering and helplessness of countless similar 
patients, constantly indulging in slandering TCM, 
and even regard slandering TCM as their own skills.


After long-term blind thinking, those guys have 
indeed mastered some tricks, one of which often 
makes them so proud that they can never extricate
themselves from it,  that is the so-called logical 
consistency.


In fact, we do often hear the very consistent 
logical trap they have woven.



For example, when a patient is sent to the 
hospital for treatment, we may hear something 
like the following logical trap :


1. When the patient has been treated with TCM, 
if the patient gets effective treatment at this 
time, those guys may say that it's okay if not 
treated and the patient may heal on his own.

But if the treatment is ineffective, those guys 
may become abnormally excited and keep 
complaining that TCM is delaying the treatment, 
and thay may say that if they themselves were  
to treat it, it would never be ineffective !


2. But when the patient has been treated by 
Western medicine, if it is an effective treatment 
at this time, those guys may say

 "Thanks to the timely arrival of the patient 
for treatment, otherwise it would have been 
too late to save .


However, if the treatment is ineffective, those 
guys may say 

" We have done our best, it would have 
been better if the patient had been sent 
here for treatment earlier.”

,
If you occasionally hear such remarks, it's 
not a big deal.

But if you frequently hear such remarks, you 
should take note:

Because this logically consistent argument is 
essentially a form of sophistry, meaning that 
under any circumstances, no matter what the 
outcome after treatment, this sophistry can 
provide those guys with a seemingly reasonable 
excuse to justify their own actions or to belittle 
TCM's treatment, while making it impossible 
for others to refute any more.


In fact, this kind of scammer logic is really 
extremely harmful because it possesses 
the following three characteristics:


3.1 The only concern of this scammer logic 
is whether the patient has been treated by 
TCM or Western medicine, rather than the 
primary issue that medical science should 
be concerned with, which is the treatment 
effect.


3.2. This kind of scammer logic is 
consistent in form and has the 
characteristic of content independence

This kind of scammer logic only needs 
to reason based on whether it is treated 
with TCM or Western medicine. 

If it is treated with TCM, then those guys 
use some words to belittle TCM's treatment. 

But if it is treated with Western medicine, 
then they use the other words to praise 
Western medicine treatment

This kind of scammer logic ensures that 
their reasoning is 100% independent of 
the condition, treatment, efficacy or time.

From this, it can be seen that this kind of  
scammer logic is indeed a bottomless trap, 
where any content can be loaded into it, 
and there is also universality in form. 

At the same time, it can ensure that the 
conclusions drawn from this scammer logic 
always meet the conclusions predetermined 
by those guys, which can both belittle TCM 
and boast themselves!


3.3 Logical self consistency

This kind of scammer logic can achieve 
logical consistency in form, which makes 
those guys appear knowledgeable and 
logical. 

Even if someone else feels confused, he 
may feel unable to refute it.


But in fact, this is the malicious usage of 
logical reasoning !

Moreover, this type of scammer logic is indeed
being abused now and then or here and there.


So, as patients or potential patients, we must 
learn to promptly and quickly identify this 
kind of scammer logic.

If we truly master the skills to identify 
this scammer logic in a timely and rapid 
manner, then we have implanted "logic 
antibodies specifically designed to 
recognize scamsinto our own cognitive 
system.

And once we implant such specialized logic 
antibodies for identifying scams into our 
cognitive system, we can ensure that we can 
quickly identify all scams from now on.


As matter of fact, it is very simple to 
identify such scams as long as all of 
us keep a close eye on both objective 
facts and actual therapeutic effects.

If some guy insists on denying a large 
number of objective facts regardless of 
the actual therapeutic effect contained 
in these objective facts, then we need 
to be very careful because this guy may 
be a professional fraudster .

So, if we remain numb to this kind of scammer 
logic for a long time, and even think that this 
scammer logic is reasonable, then those guys 
can completely destroy our TCM even only by 
this kind of scammer logic and they even have 
no sense of guilt at all !

In fact, TCM can effectively treat many 
diseases, which has been proven by a 
large number of objective facts. 

Moreover, such objective facts continue 
to emerge, and such objective facts are 
constantly introduced on television. 

Even if some people cannot understand such 
objective facts, it is normal.

But it is only proves that their lack of 
understanding actually means their 
own cognition is very poor, that's all !

In order to eliminate the harm of this 
kind of poor cognition, it is necessary 
to firmly oppose the transformation 
of cognitive limitation of one guy 
person into the cognitive limitations 
of everyone, or even into professional 
standards !


Besides, since those guys are particularly 
skillful at playing games such as logical 
consistency, they may know something 
about British philosopher Wittgenstein 
very well .

Mr. Wittgenstein had long said that one 
must remain silent about things that 
cannot be clearly stated.

Of course, what Mr. Wittgenstein meant by 
silence is by no means an unconditional 
denial of many objective facts that are 
temporarily incomprehensible, otherwise 
our human being would only remain 
silently in a state of ignorance forever.

Obviously, the original intention of 
Wittgenstein's statement of keeping 
silent is 

To provide objective descriptions of 
objective facts that are temporarily
incomprehensible, in order to 
anticipate more research in the future.

At the same time, for any objective fact 
that is currently unclear, we should never 
completely deny it !


In fact, only objectively describing 
all the original objective facts ,that 
are currently unclearis , is our 
true respect for objective facts, 
professional spirit and professional 
mission.

If one completely denies any objective fact 
that he himself cannot comprehend, it has 
nothing to do with professional cognition, 
academia or logic, because any fool can 
completely deny anything he himself 
cannot comprehend !

In fact, when discussing medical issues, we 
should adhere to the core principles of 
medical science, which are based on facts, 
guided by therapeutic effects, 
patient-centered and duty oriented 
in treating diseases.


And if someone like them deliberately uses 
professional terminologies to weave scammer 
logic, and even claims it to be "logical 
consistency" in an attempt to deceive patients 
for a long time, he is truly lacking in 
professional spirit !


Because this kind of scammer logic is 
essentially a desecration of objective 
facts, actual therapeutic effects, logic 
and medical science !

From the above analysis, it can be seen 
that logic is indeed a very important 
discipline, but logic is only a kind of 
knowledge. 

Like other scientific knowledge, it has 
its own instrumental features. 

That is, as a discipline, logic can only 
play a positive role when applied 
correctly, rationally and in good 
faith


If some guy uses knowledge of logic to 
specifically construct logical traps that 
are logically consistent in form, specifically 
for professional mutual attacks, then such 
logical consistency is only a tool for 
professional professional mutual attacks. 

As a tool for professional professional 
mutual attacks, such logical consistency 
has great deception and destructive power, 
and must be highly vigilant.

In short, regarding medical science, as 
patients or potential patients, we only 
need to be interested in both objective 
facts and actual therapeutic effects, while 
we should not blindly believe in word 
games such as logical consistency, 
because not everyone has enough ability 
to timely identify scams masked by logical 
consistency !


Besides, for us patients or potential patients,



the actual therapeutic effect 
is far more important than 
logical consistency !  


( ------ Written on July 2, 2025 )



 

 for the original text  ]




0

阅读 收藏 喜欢 打印举报/Report
  

新浪BLOG意见反馈留言板 欢迎批评指正

新浪简介 | About Sina | 广告服务 | 联系我们 | 招聘信息 | 网站律师 | SINA English | 产品答疑

新浪公司 版权所有