加载中…
个人资料
  • 博客等级:
  • 博客积分:
  • 博客访问:
  • 关注人气:
  • 获赠金笔:0支
  • 赠出金笔:0支
  • 荣誉徽章:
正文 字体大小:

语义学,我为什么让学生读《道德经》

(2012-09-15 16:34:09)
标签:

语言

道德经

原理

理论建构

批评

分类: 译理发凡

         语义学,我为什么让学生读《道德经》

 

《道德经》当然不是语言学著作,但我上语言学课,尤其是语言哲学、语义学时,推荐的第一部参考书就是《道德经》。这当然不是因为它文采斐然章章锦绣字字珠玑,而是它蕴含人类把握世界及自身的根本原理,体现于语言研究便是理论建构和批评所最易理解和最易把握的标尺。没想到两千多年前老子就给我们的科学研究提供了最根本最有效的方法。在老子两百年之后西方出现了迄今已统治西方学术两千多年的巨人——亚里斯多德,他与老子竟是不谋而合。

道是什么?我们无以把握,老子在第一章就说了的——你所能言说的道,却不是道本身,但道却是存在的,且是无处不在的,连屎尿也不能例外——庄子有言:“道在尿溺”。这正如西方的上帝,祂也是无处不在的(omnipresent)。西方的上帝其实就是道——《约翰福音》说:“太初有道,道与上帝同在,道即上帝,上帝即道”。你会说东方的道与西方的道不是一个。真的吗?依据何在?你如果有形上思维,你会认识到道是统一的,这也包括赫拉克利特的道。这个我们且不论,那么这个玄虚的东西对我们到底意味着什么呢?我们也不论其形而上学意义了,就我们人本身而言,道是我们认知世界乃至从事一切科学研究必须借助的东西。它大致可以理解为亚里斯多德所说的“形式”——形式是西方哲学中最关键的一个词,离开它你根本无法理解西方哲学、西方文化。你也别吹牛,你真的知道西方文化的精髓吗?道是最上位的存在了,相当于亚里斯多德所说的第三实体。难怪《易经》如是说:“形而上者谓之道,形而下者谓之器”。在认识论上,我可以这样断言,没有道就没有器,而摒弃了道,你根本无法认识器。后现代学术的一切谬论都源于对道的颠覆,尽管它无时不在道之中。后现代学术即便刨除它恶搞的一面,其理论体系也是悖论的、自相矛盾的,比如翻译学中的文化派、语言学中的认知语言学,等等。

西方的逻辑精髓便是A=A,是经典逻辑的基础或者说全部,而后现代学术依据的是A=-A。我承认A=-A是一种视角,但它必须在A=A的条件下才成立,后现代学术竟然是颠覆A=A的。其实,A=-A蕴含A与-A的二元对立。从A=A与A=-A的关系你便可以在最根本的层面认识一切理论的是是非非了。关于二元对立或二元互斥的人类法则,《道德经》第二章说得很到位:

天下皆知美之为美,斯恶已;皆知善之为善,斯不善矣。有无相生,难易相成,长短相形,高下相盈,音声相和,前后相随,恒也。

你看,说得多好,这与西方哲学中的mutually exclusive、excluded middle真是异曲同工,妙极了。反观我们的哲学、文学、翻译学、语言学领域,竟然充斥着对二元论(binarism)的否定!以所谓的模糊性、连续统来否定明晰性、离散性,只能说明对人类法则的懵懂或肆意篡改。

当然,中国学者对二元论的否定并非源发于中国人自身,而是西方“启蒙”、“解构”、“殖民”的结果。我们何必拾人牙慧呢?何况这又不是牙慧呢?我们该有点自己的主张了,我们该迷途知返了。那就先返回老子吧。

 

道可道,非常道。

名可名,非常名。

无名,天地之始也;

有名,万物之母也。

故恒无欲也,以观其眇;

恒有欲也,以观其所徼。

两者同出,异名同谓。

玄之又玄,众眇之门。

The Word that can be worded is not the Word per se

The Name that can be named is not the Name proper

Void of a name is the beginning of Heaven and earth

Real with a name is the mother of all things

Being eternally void is the access to subtlety

Being eternally real is the approach to boundedness

The two are of the same origin, the same but with different names

The profound of the profoundest is the entrance to all subtleties.

  

天下皆知美之为美,恶已;

皆知善,斯不善矣。

有无之相生也,

难易之相成也,

长短之相刑也, 

高下之相盈也,

音声之相和也,

先后之相随,

恒也。

是以圣人居无为之事,

行不言之教,万物作而弗始也,

为而弗志也,成功而弗居也。

夫唯弗居,是以弗去。

 

All the world know beauty is beauty, because of ugliness,

All know goodness is goodness, because of non-goodness.

What is real and what is void generate each other

What is difficult and what is easy beget each other

What is long and what is short contrast each other

What is high and what is low complement each other

What is sound and what is voice attune each other 

What is front and what is rear follow each other

This is what is eternal.

Therefore the sages leave things as they are

They teach without inculcation,let things arise instead of raising them

They work without deliberation,achieve but not credit themselves 

Just because they do not credit themselves, they have nothing to lose

第一章

道可道,非常道;名可名,非常名。
无名,天地之始;有名,万物之母。
故常无欲,以观其妙;常有欲,以观其徼。
此两者,同出而异名,同谓之玄。
玄之又玄,众妙之门。

 

许渊冲版:

 

Chapter I

The divine law may be spoken of,
but it is not the common law.
Things may be named,
but names are not the things.
In the beginning heaven and earth are nameless;
when named, all things become known.
So we should be free from desires
in order to understand the internal
mystery of the divine law;
and we should have desires
in order to observe its external manifestations.
Internal mystery and external manifestations
come from the same origin,
but have different names,
They may be called essence.
The essential of the essence
is the key to the understanding of all mysteries.

第二章

天下皆知美之为美,斯恶已;皆知善之为善,斯不善已。
故有无相生,难易相成,长短相形,高下相倾,音声相和,前后相随。
是以圣人处无为之事,行不言之教,万物作焉而不辞,生而不有,为而不恃,功成而弗居。夫唯弗居,是以不去。

Chapter 2

If all men in the world know what is fair,
then it is unfair.
If all men know what is good,
then it is not good.
For "to be" and "not be" co-exist,
There cannot be one without the other:
without "difficult", there cannot be "easy";
without "long", there cannot be "short";
without "high", there cannot be "low";
without sound, there can be no voice;
without "before", there cannot be "after";
The contrary complement each other.
Therefore the sage does everything without interference,
teaches everyone without persuasion,
and lets everything begin uninitiated
and grow unpossessed.
Everything is done without being his deed,
and succeeds without being his success.
Only when success belongs to nobody
does it belong to everyone.

第三章

不尚贤,使民不争;不贵难得之货,使民不为盗;不见可欲,使民心不乱。
是以圣人之治,虚其心,实其腹;弱其志,强其骨。常使民无知无欲,使夫智不敢为也。为无为,则无不治。

Chapter 3

Honor on man
as that none would contend for honor.
Value no rare goods
so that none would steal or rob.
Display nothing desirable
lest people be tempted and disturbed.
Therefore the sage rules
by purifying people's soul,
filing their bellies,
weakening their wills
and strengthening their bones.
He always keeps them knowledgeless
and desireless
so that the clever dare not interfere.
Where there is not interference,
there is order.

第四章

道冲而用之,或不盈。
渊兮,似万物之宗。(挫其锐,解其纷,和其光,同其尘。)湛兮,似或存。
吾不知谁之子,象帝之先。

Chapter 4

The divine law is formless,
its use is inexhaustible.
It is endless,
whence come all things
where the sharp is blunted,
the knots are united,
the glare is softened,
all look like dust.
Apparent,
it seems to exist.
I do not know when it came;
it seems to exist before God.

第五章

天地不仁,以万物为刍狗;圣人不仁,以百姓为刍狗。
天地之间,其犹橐龠!虚而不屈,动而愈出。
多言数穷,不如守中。

Chapter 5

Heaven and earth are ruthless,
they treat everything as straw or dog.
The sage is ruthless,
he treats everyone as straw or dog.
Are not heaven and earth
like a pair of bellows?
Empty, it won't be exhausted;
Forced, more air will come out.
If more is said than done,
it would be better to take the mean.

第六章

谷神不死,是谓玄牝。
玄牝之门,是谓天地根。
绵绵若存,用之不勤。

Chapter 6

The vale spirit never dies,
it is the mysterious womb.
The door to the mysterious womb
is the origin of heaven and earth.
It lasts as if it ever existed;
when used, it is inexhaustible.

第七章

天长地久,天地所以能长且久者,以其不自生,故能长生。
是以圣人后其身而身先,外其身而身存。非以其无私邪?故能成其私。

Chapter 7

Heaven and earth exist for ever.
The reason why their exist so long
is not that they want to exist;
where there is no want,
to be and not be are one.
Therefore for the sage
the last becomes the first,
the out becomes the in.
As he is selfless,
all becomes his self.

第八章

上善若水,水善利万物而不争。处众人之所恶,故几于道。
居善地,心善渊,与善仁,言善信,正善治,事善能,动善时。
夫唯不争,故无尤。

Chapter 8

The highest good is like water
Water benefits everything by giving
without taking or contending.
It likes the place others dislike,
so it follows closely the divine law.
The place should be low,
the mind broad,
the gifts kind,
the speech trustworthy,
the rule sound,
the deed well-done,
the action timely.
Without contention,
a man is blameless.

第九章

持而盈之,不如其已;揣而锐之,不可长保。
金玉满堂,莫之能守。富贵而骄,自遗其咎。
功遂身退,天之道也!

Chapter 9

Don't hold your fill
but refrain from excess.
A whetted and sharpened sword
cannot be sharp for ever.
A houseful of gold and jade
cannot be safeguarded.
Arrogance of wealth and power
will bring ruin.
Withdrawal after success
conforms to the divine law.

第十章

载营魄抱一,能无离乎?
专气致柔,能婴儿乎?
修除玄览,能无疵乎?
爱民治国,能无智乎?
天门开阖,能为雌乎?
明白四达,能无知乎?
(生之畜之,生而不有,为而不恃,长而不宰。是为玄德。)

Chapter 10

Can body and soul united
never sever?
Can the controlled breath be
softened as a baby's?
Can the purified mental mirror be
free from blemish?
Can a people-loving ruler not interfere in the state affairs?
Can the lower doors not open and close
as the upper doors in the heaven?
Is it possible to understand and make
understand without knowledge?
Give life and make live,
but lay no claim,
benefit but do not interfere,
lead but do not rule,
Such is the mysterious virtue.

第十一章 
               
三十辐共一毂,当其无,有车之用。
埏埴以为器,当其无,有器之用。
凿户牖以为室,当其无,有室之用。
故有之以为利,无之以为用。

Chapter 11

Thirty spokes radiate from a hub.
When there is nothing in the hub,
the wheel can roll.
Turn clay to make a vessel.
When empty,
the vessel can be used.
Build a room with doors and windows.
When empty,
the room can be used as dwelling.
When there is something, it is beneficial;
When empty, it is useful.

第十二章

五色令人目盲,五音令人耳聋,五味令人口爽,驰骋畋猎令人心发狂,难得之货令人行妨。
是以圣人为腹不为目,故去彼取此。

Chapter 12

The fiver colors may confuse the eye.
The five sounds may deafen the ear.
The five tastes may spoil the palate.
Riding and hunting may madden the mind.
Rare goods may tempt one to do evil.
Therefore the sage satisfies the belly rather than the eye.
He prefers the former to the latter.

第十三章

宠辱若惊,贵大患若身。
何谓宠辱若惊?宠为下,得之若惊,失之若惊是谓宠辱若惊。
何谓贵大患若身?吾所以有大患者,为吾有身;及吾无身,吾有何患。
故贵以身为天下,若可寄天下;爱以身为天下,若可托天下。

Chapter 13

Praise and blame disturb the mind;
Fortune and misfortune affect the body.
Why is the mind disturbed?
Praise and blame are like ups and downs.
The mind is troubled with rise and fall.
So is it troubled by praise and blame.
How can fortune and misfortune affect the body?
Because we have a body.
If we had not a body,
how can we be affected?
If you value the world as your body,
then the world may confide in you.
If you love the world as your body,
then the world may be entrusted to you.

第十四章

视之不见名曰夷,听之不闻名曰希,抟之不得名曰微。此三者不可致诘,故混而为一。其上不徼,其下不昧,绳绳不可名,复归於无物。是谓无状之状,无物之象,是谓惚恍。迎之不见其首,随之不见其後。执古之道以御今之有。能知古始,是谓道纪。

Chapter 14

What cannot be seen is invisible,
What cannot be heard is inaudible,
What cannot be touched is intangible.
These there, unfathomable,
blend into one.
Up, it is not bright;
down, it is not dark.
Like a nameless endless string,
it ends in nothing.
It is a formless form,
an image of nothing.
It seems to be and not to be.
Before it, you cannot see its front;
after it, you cannot see its rear.
Ruling over the present with the law of the past,
you can know the beginning of antiquity.
Such is the rule of the divine law.

第十五章

古之善为道者,微妙玄通,深不可识。夫唯不可识,故强为之容。豫兮其若冬涉川;犹兮其若畏四邻;俨兮其若容;涣兮其若冰之将释;敦兮其若朴;旷兮其若谷;混兮其若浊;孰能浊以静之?徐清。孰能安以动之?徐生。保此道者不欲盈。夫唯不盈,故能蔽而新成。

Chapter XV

The ancients followed the divine law,
subtle, delicate, mysterious, communicative,
too deep to be understood.
Not objectively understood,
it can only be subjectively described.
The ancients were circumspect as crossing a frozen river,
watchful as fearful of hostile neighbors,
reserved as an unacquainted guest,
softened as melting ice,
natural as uncarved block,
vacant as a vale,
and obscure as a muddy stream.
Who could calm the turbid water?
It could be slowly turned clean.
Who could stir the stale water?
It could be slowly revived.
Those who follow the divine law
will not be full to the brim.
Only those who do not go to excess
can renew what is worn out.

 

 

0

阅读 收藏 喜欢 打印举报/Report
  

新浪BLOG意见反馈留言板 欢迎批评指正

新浪简介 | About Sina | 广告服务 | 联系我们 | 招聘信息 | 网站律师 | SINA English | 产品答疑

新浪公司 版权所有