狄拉克的研究生生活与导师
(2014-01-04 20:38:08)
标签:
狄拉克量子力学形式逻辑 |
分类: 高等量子力学 |
On Monday, 1
October 1923, when he walked through the stone portals of St
John ’s
College to register his arrival, he entered an unfamiliar world
of tradition,
camaraderie and privilege.
College life
reflected the origins of British academia. The earliest
scholars had
been monks, all wearing the same clothes, and all going about
their contemplative
lives within an agreed set of timetables and rules. In 1923,
all the
official students of the college and the rest of the university
were male, each of
them required to wear a gown and mortarboard in public. Any
student who
went into town incorrectly attired knew he ran the risk of being
nabbed by one of
the university’s private policemen (proctors or ‘progs’) or
their
assistants
(‘bulldogs’), who roamed the streets after dusk. A
transgression of the
dress code was punished by a fine of 6s 8d, no laughing matter for
any young
man keen to preserve his spare money, though not nearly as serious
as the
penalty for being caught with a woman in his room.
The students
were waited on hand and foot. By 6 a. m., the invariably
female bed-makers
(‘bedders’) were hanging around the stone staircases, ready
to begin
their morning’s work. The gyps – man-servants –were available all
day
to clean, wash
up and run errands for the students and for the Fellows
(also known
as‘dons’). Such service was not, however, available to young Dirac
in his
first year. He spent it in a cold and damp shoebox of a room in a
four-storey
Victorian house, a fifteen-minute walk from St John’s, sharing
with two
other lodgers. At a cost of almost £15 a term, the landlady
Miss Josephine
Brown delivered coals and wood for their fires, supplied gas for
the lamps
that lit their musty little rooms, provided them with crockery
and cleaned
their boots. Like all the other landladies approved by the
university,
Miss Brown was
obliged to keep a record of any failure of Dirac’s to
return home by
10 p.m. Always early to bed, he would not have given her any
trouble.
Dirac had his
first experience of grand dining in Hall, where he took
his meals.
The room is magnificently appointed, with an elaborately
decorated wooden
ceiling, Gothic stained-glass windows and dark-wood panels hung
with portraits
of some of the college’s most distinguished alumni,
including William
Wordsworth. The formalities began at 7.30 p.m. with the arrival of
the procession
of Fellows and other senior members of college at their long
table, under
the calm gaze of Lady Margaret, whose portrait in oils hung above
them. The
students were already seated in their gowns along the six rows
of benches,
either side of three long rows of tables, each of them set with
crisp white
linen tablecloths, the college coat of arms worked into the
damask.
It was expected
that every head should be dutifully cocked, every pair
of hands
solemnly crossed in silence as one of the students read the Latin
grace from a
tablet. The moment he finished, a hundred conversations surged to
fill the
hall.
The menus,
written by hand in French, described the three courses in a
style that
would meet the approval of a Paris gourmet. The meal might begin
with scalloped
cod or lentil soup, move on to a main course of jugged hare
or boiled
tongue and end with gooseberry pie and cream or a plate of cheese
with cress
and radishes, or even sardines on toast. Much of this rich food
was wasted
on Dirac, whose poor digestion made him favour more basic fare,
which he ate
slowly and in only modest quantities.
Dirac’s fellow
diners consisted mainly of the young men of the
Brideshead generation
(in Evelyn Waugh’s novel, Charles Rider and Sebastian Flyte
were then
beginning their final year over in Oxford). Most of them had
been privately
educated at schools such as Eton, Harrow and Rugby, where they
had
learned Latin
and Greek and the art of discoursing easily about
the fashionable
topics of the day, such as T. S. Eliot’s modernist poetry, or
of passing
supercilious judgement on Shaw’s latest provocation. Dirac was
ill equipped
to join them.
Every night,
alcohol circulated up and down the dinner table in
Hall, loosening
the students’ tongues, freeing them to shout ever more loudly
to make
themselves heard over the din. Amid the cacophony, Dirac sat
impassively, a
teetotaller in the Methodist tradition, silently sipping water from
his
glass. He had
left Bristol never having consumed a cup of tea or coffee,
so his
first sampling of these drinks was an event for him. Neither much
appealed to him,
though he did have the occasional weak and milky tea, its
caffeine dose
scarcely exceeding homoeopathic levels. Decades later, he told one
of his children
that he drank coffee only to give himself courage before giving
a presentation.
Dirac’s manner
at the dinner table became the stuff of legend. He had
no interest
in small talk, and it was common for him to sit through
several courses
without saying a word or even acknowledging the students sitting
next to him.
Too diffident even to ask someone to pass the salt and pepper, he
made no
demands at all on his fellow diners and felt no obligation to
maintain the momentum
of any dialogue. Every opening conversational gambit would
be met
with silence or with a simple yes or no. According to one story still
in
circulation in St John’s
College, Dirac once responded to the comment
‘It’s a bit
rainy, isn’t it?’ by walking to the window, returning to his
seat, and then stating ‘It is not now raining.’
Such behaviour quickly persuaded
his colleagues that further questioning was both unwelcome
and pointless.
Yet he did prefer to eat in company and to hear intelligent
people
talking about
serious matters, and it was by listening to such
conversations that
Dirac slowly learned about llife outside science.
He was fortunate
to go up to Cambridge at this time. The colleges had
just seen
the departure of the last students in military uniform, which
took precedence
over academic dress until the students were officially
demobilised. Now
that Britain was under no threat of another international conflict,
this
was an
optimistic time, and the next generation of students was anxious to
get back to
academic work. Dirac was studying in the university’s
largest department,
mathematics, famous for its high standards and
its competitiveness.
Among the students, the highest cachet was reserved
for those
who both excelled in their studies and who competed successfully
in sport,
which is why Hassé had thought it relevant to remark in his
reference for
Dirac that he ‘played no games’. Most students took at least some
part in the
social life in Cambridge –chatting in the new coffee bars, singing
in
choirs, slipping
out in the evening to the cinema or to see an ancient
Greek play.
None of this interested Dirac. Even by the standards of the
most ambitious
swot, he was exceptionally focused on his work, though dedication
is no
guarantee of success, as thousands of students find out every year.
He had
been
consistently top of the class in the academic backwater of Bristol,
but he had
no idea whether he would be able to compete with the best students
in Cambridge.
From the moment Dirac and his colleagues
arrived, the dons were
watching every one of them, always on the lookout for a student of
truly exceptional
calibre – in Cambridge parlance, ‘a first-rate
man’.
It did not take
long for the extent of Dirac’s talent to become clear to
his supervisor,
Fowler, who took a brisk interest in his progress, giving
him carefully
chosen problems to tackle, constantly encouraging him to hone
his mathematics.
Students who brought Fowler a good piece of work were
rewarded with
his favourite exclamation, ‘Splendid!’, and, more often than not, a
pat on the
back. He was an inspirational presence in the department,
but sometimes
unpopular: by spending much of his time working at home or on
trips to the
Continental centres of physics, he often frustrated the students
who yearned
for the succour of his advice. But Dirac was not so dependent; he
was content
to be lightly supervised, to work alone and to generate many of
his own projects. Soon, he
realised that he had been lucky to have been
allocated the
most effective supervisor of theoretical physics in
Cambridge.
Fowler’s manner
was unique in the mathematics department. The
prevailing culture
was intensely formal, and the academics – every one of them male
and dressed
like a banker – kept their heads down in their offices and
college
rooms. The use
of first names was all but forbidden: even the friendliest
of colleagues
referred to each other by their surnames and, outside the
common room,
conversations rarely lasted longer than politeness deemed
necessary.
Opportunities
for them to meet outside the college were minimal as there
was no
tradition of communal tea and coffee breaks and no programme of
seminars. Nor was
there any of the staff–student socialising now almost de rigueur
in
modern
university life. Apart from Fowler’s guidance, Dirac was left to
his own
devices. He soon settled into a private routine that would have
rendered him
invisible among the thousands of his fellow students. With no room
of his
own in the
department, he worked on problems that Fowler set him,
read recommended
books and the latest journals and reviewed the notes he had
made during
the lectures. He relaxed only on
Sundays. If the weather
was fine,
he set off in the morning for a few hours’ walk, dressed in the
suit he
wore all week,
his hands joined behind his back, both feet pointing
outwards as he
made his way around the countryside in his metronomic stride. One
of his colleagues
said he looked like ‘the bridegroom in an Italian
wedding photograph’.
Dirac would put
his calculations firmly at the back of his mind, aiming
to clear
his head so that he could approach his work fresh on Monday
morning. Pausing
only to eat his packed lunch, he looked every inch the city
gent inspecting
the local countryside: to the north, there was the winding
valley of the
river Great Ouse and to the east, the geometrical network of
fenland drains
and Tudor-style buildings with their Dutch gables. He would return
in time
for dinner at St John’s and then walk back to his digs through
the foggy
backstreets of Cambridge, most of them unlit. On Monday morning, he
was ready
for another six days’uninterrupted
study.
The Strangest Man