TCMs.Scientificity.Without.Any.Question
(2023-07-29 09:13:04)分类: 医学通论.中医科学 |
In my opinion ,
it is nothing but farce to argument
about
the scientificity of our TCM (
Traditional
Chinese
Medicine ) !
But during
these farces , our TCM scholars
are so
poor and
so helpless that even make me feel
fantastic
!
And at the same
time , practitioners from western
medicine argue
so irrationally that everyone
could
fell it too absurd .
How ridiculous
!
As a matter of
fact , our Chinese nation
should have
reached
the following consensus about
the TCM's
scientific :
1. The effectiveness of
TCM is the solid foundation
of
its science
Our TCM
can effectively treat many difficult
and
complex
diseases , as evidenced by a large
number
of
actual cases .
However , for
similar cases , western medicine is often
powerless
.
So , it alone
is enough to make western medical
doctors shame and to wipe out all
scientific arguments
about
TCM !
If someone
continues with unreasonable demands
,
he perhaps has
an ulterior motive !
As we know ,
our TCM's effectiveness has
certified by
the large
historical cases and evidences
, and
TCM's
effectiveness
will never be
easily denied by
western
medical
theory ,
which still something immature
!
Because the
practice is the unique
criterion for testing
theory ,
that is the standard for medical science either
!
It's the
responsibility of TCM scholars
to perfect the
It is better ,
of course ,if we can get help from western
medicine
knowledge in the process of
TCM's
improvement
.
But we don't
have to seek to fawn on
western medicine
!
Meanwhile , we
don't have to confine or even eager
to
be
servants of western medicine !
2. The
effectiveness verification is
more important
than the scientific
validation during the long
history of
human society development !
than scientific
verification
For
example :
If
people dared to start eating
rice only after
they
had understood
the molecular structure and the
nutritional value of
rice , it would be a
problem
whether
the human beings
existed on this world
now
!
Similarly , our
TCM ( Traditional Chinese
Medicine )
is an
inexhaustible and effective source of
knowledge
for
treating diseases and preserving health
.
So ,
when western medicine really
understand our
TCM , we may
have already saved countless lifes ,
and then the
history of our TCM may have up
to
six thousand years !
If a
person insists on
despising the importance
of
validity
, then his intelligence may be less than
an
animal ,
for the animal maybe often cure its
pains
by
itself according to the
validity or experiences
!
3. Either
TCM or western medicine has respective
development logic ,
there is no obvious reference
between TCM and
western medicine .
Alternatively , it is impossible to
understand the
reference
or correlation between TCM and western
medicine by the
current limited theoretical
level .
Even TCM
scholars often explain the theory of
TCM
to doctors of western
medicine , but some of them
never
believe our TCM theory
!
So , It is no
need to waste time again !
On the
other hand , it is infeasible to explain
the
theory of
TCM ( Traditional Chinese
Medicine )
with
western
medicine theory .
We should
stop the similar arguments as long as
we
had
understood the following two analyses :
3.1 In
fact , if someone always acts as a
spoiler who
is
hostile
to our TCM forever , his level
of knowledge or
analysis
of the problem is not more than that of
our
junior
high school students .
When
the students in
a junior middle school
are
proving geometry
problems , they may find some
geometric problems
are too difficult to prove .
But if
they draw one or several properly
auxiliary
lines
, the problems will be
smoothly solved .
If at
this moment , someone with a poor head comes
to question :
“There is no line
obviously , why did you draw
these lines
? It is a fraud as long as you do it !
”
When you
have heard such a sophistry , perhaps you
will keep far from him
.
Unfortunately , some western medical scholars
are
just
something like such a student with a poor head
!
So , it
is merely no important to argue or discuss with
them at
all !
Note
: W e can explain the
TCM's meridian theory
by this method .
3.2 Mr. John is a very famous
English poet .
Suddenly
one day , one of his friends ,
a translater ,
came to
complained to him :
“Hi ! John , Your poems are composed just so
so ,
because we can't
translate them . ”
After
that , this poet always considers how to
make
it easier
to translate his work , so that he
makes
much
trouble to express poetic
flavour at last
!
So , in
the end , he can hardly write any poetry
!
But in fact ,
for this poet , the first thing to
consider
is how to
perfectly express his poetic ideas ,
rather
than how to
translate them .
Similarly , the
primary task of our TCM is to effectively
treat diseases
, not to worry about any loiterer
.
Or we can
ask :
Is
Traditional Chinese Medicine obligated to
translate
into
Western Medicine ?
Is it necessary
to translate Traditional Chinese Medicine
into Western
medicine ?
Note: We can explain the
TCM's theory of five
elements
by this kind of method .
4. Science
is developing forever , and so is
western
medicine
.
Now days ,
western medicine can not explain TCM ,
but it is only
because the limitation of Western
medicine itself
.
Perhaps
, western medical doctors will
understand
our TCM
after it has made progress in one thousand
years
.
But now ,
doctors of western medicine
cannot pretend
to
understand everything , and then
use something
called
"Scientific" against our TCM just because
they
themselves don't
understand our TCM
at all!
And no one can
impose his
own limitations on our
TCM
!
Because
this kind of imposition is the robber
logic .
5. A petty
trick in the micro world vs A
great
wisdomin
the macro world .
Some persons
are always addicted to
molecular
movements , so
that they often making the treatment
of many simple
diseases extremely complex , but the treatment effect is often
unsatisfactory .
They may always
be busy in the micro world , or they
may never be
able to free themselves from the
micro
world , so that
they cannot consider the actual
treatment
effect .
However , our
TCM can rationally observe problems
from a
systematic and macro perspective and solve
problems
effectively .
So , from this
alone , we can conclude that :
Western
medicine is just a hodgepodge of various
technologies ,
and it is indeed a relatively mature
experimental
technology , but it is far from a
science , so
that at best , it is only an
experimental
knowledge
.
But our TCM is
truly a science worthy of the name !
6. Maybe
someone always attributes the
successful
cases of TCM
treatment to coincidences , and he
attributes the
failure cases of TCM treatment to
inevitability
, then let us together to send him
a
nickname for
free:
TRICKER !
--------
Written in 2014