What's ur take of human right in the
U.S.
The problem with the "assesssment of Human Rights in the
United States," is that many people distort the concept of human
rights. Human rights violations are not simply a
laundry list of all the bad things about a
country. That would be like saying China has bad
human rights because the pollution gives people lung cancer, or
poor people don't have enough food to eat. Human
rights violations include actions where the government deliberately
violates people of rights they are "owed" simply because they are
human. For example, racism is often cited in
China as a human rights violation in the United
States. However, racism is not systematically put
into place by the government today as it was in the South before
the civil rights movement. Rather, racism is the
fault of individuals' own ignorance and
preconceptions. Another often cited human rights
violation in the US is crime. Yes, the US has a
high crime rate, but is this the fault of the government or the
fault of individuals? Could more be done to stop
it? Probably, but running a country is not an
easy task, and crime is not the only issue on the
table. This is just like saying China violates
its citizens human rights because more people die in car accidents
in China than any other country. Yes, it is
something that needs to be improved, but it certainly is not a
human rights issue..
.....all that being said...the concept of Human Rights is
a concept rooted in the ideologies of Western
Democracies. What qualifies as acceptable
behavior can change from situation to situation.
For example, most people would agree that stealing in and of itself
is bad. However, if you had nothing to eat, and
the only way to survive was to steal, we would probably be more
open to the idea. Thus the concept of human
rights. China is much less developed than the
United States, not to mention they have 5 times as many
people. It is unrealistic to expect a government
like China's to react the same as those of developed western
nations in all situations, especially in regards to "human
rights." The leaders of China today have all
lived through the Cultural Revolution and Great Leap
Forward. They have experienced
far more hardship than those of us living our cushy American lives
in the suburbs. And in order to improve the
quality of life for 1.3 billion Chinese people, sacrifices will
have to be made. Sometimes these sacrifices may
seem unacceptable to Westerners, because these sacrifices are not
needed in our developed countries, and someday they will not be
needed in China either. It is very easy for
Westerners to forget, that China still has a lot of catching up to
do with the West. (I am not saying this is
China's fault, just a matter of fact). It is
unfair for us to judge China's actions in 2007 based on the United
States' expectations in 2007.
Just look at what was happening in our country not that long
ago...slavery, extermination of the indians,
etc.
I just wish the Chinese government would take this
outlook, rather than ridiculously criticize the "human rights" in
the United States. This would
get them much more sympathy from the
West.
www.benross.net/wordpress
加载中,请稍候......