标签:
杂谈 |
我在《信息甄别术:分清一手信息和二手信息》:http://weibo.com/p/1001603819206276728308?mod=zwenzhang这篇文章里,用克罗地亚老妇人的事件做了案例,我的判断是假消息。
我在豆瓣发布了同名文章后,一位读者freya君指出,这条新闻可能是真的,并给出了来源网址:
http://www.foxnews.com/story/2008/05/16/woman-dead-body-lies-in-flat-for-35-years/
这个网址我前几天一直没能打开,今天终于可以。
我认真阅读了原文,如果我理解没有错误的话,可以得出如下结论:
1、2008年,克罗地亚发现一具已死35年的女尸,名为Hedviga Golik,约死于1973年。
2、新闻中没有特别具体地描述Hedviga Golik的样子,只有一句说遗骸在床上。
如果以上有错误,请更正我,我的英语的确不算好。
建立在以上基础上,我对之前的说法做出澄清:
1、我刷新自己的认识,这个世界上的确是有人逝去35年未被发觉(指的是在自己家中而非失踪在战场等地,后者相对来说寻常)。在这点上,我之前的判断,有一定的错误。
2、很抱歉,“克罗地亚老妇端坐电视机前 死亡42年才被发现”仍然不正确,新闻链接不能证明这个说法正确。我据以判断这个消息是假的依据就是“端坐”,2008年被发现,不等于加上7年就变成了42年。FOX新闻中没有图片,图片中人骨的坐姿、手和电视机、看上去很干净的环境,都会影响人的判断。
错了的地方,就认,这没什么可丢人的,不能死咬着错误坚持。
不过,还存疑的地方,也不能就此盖棺定论。
很感谢freya君给出新闻链接,相比另外的指责但是没有给出任何佐证,我更欣赏这样的做法,也让我增强严谨性。
考虑到有可能有人像我一样不容易打开链接,附上原新闻内容供直接访问:
Published May 16, 2008Associated Press
Governments have changed. War erupted and ended. Neighbors had children, and then grandchildren. But Hedviga Golik never left her tiny apartment in Croatia's capital — until her mummified body was carried out this week, 35 years after she died.
Police said Friday that no one ever reported Golik missing and no one has come to claim her body.
Residents of her loft building in downtown Zagreb had broken into Golik's flat after deciding that the apartment should belong to them, and not to her. Startled by the remains in bed, they called police.
Forensics experts said Golik likely died in 1973, about the time a neighbor last saw her. Expert Davor Strinovic said she seemed to have died of natural causes, but "it's almost impossible to say for certain" after so much time.
Some of Golik's neighbors claimed she had talked about going abroad.
Experts said her windows had been open, likely diminishing the smell. It remained unclear who — if anyone — was paying her bills and who exactly owned the apartment. In the 1970s, when Golik died, apartments were state-owned.
Neighbors now argue the apartment should be divided among the remaining tenants.
The discovery of Golik's body on Tuesday prompted media debates on how it is possible for a woman to die so long ago without anyone noticing. One local journalist said it showed people were becoming more alienated.
"My dear neighbors! Please keep on being curious and a bit tiresome, as you have been so far," Merita Arslani wrote in the Jutarnji list daily.
后一篇:让自己成为一个盛纳美丽的容器