April 20, 2004
The Israelis and Palestinians have to learn to
live with each other, co-exist, peacefully, and recognise the hard
fact that the other side will be a permanent presence: the Jewish
state in the historic Palestinian and the Palestinian state in West
Bank and Gaza Strip.
Both sides have to act pragmatically and
discard unrealistic mythologies or purely ideologically grounded
grandiose objectives, which are in fundamental conflict with real
circumstances.
The Israeli
side
●
The Israelis have to abide
to the Resolution 242 of United Nation Security Council which
requests Israeli to withdraw from the areas it has annexed in the
1967-war. The Israeli right-wing, chauvinists, nationalists,
Zionists, settlers/settle movements have to accept this is the most
basic step towards a peace process, and to understand that their
occupation of Palestinian territory is illegal, unjustified and
condemned by the United Nation and international community at
large.
●
Israelis should stop to
undertake “targeted assassination” against leaders of Hamas and
other Palestinian opposition groups, recognising the fact , at
least implicitly, that:
★
These opposition Palestinian
groups are the only armed resistant force that Palestinians
have;
★
That the Israeli’s side is
undertaking act of terrorism – an activity they condemn – in the
name of state. Israeli needs not to profess this recognition but
should nevertheless comprehend it from their heart. Israeli has to
reassess its whole approach in handling the affair and understand
what give cause to those terrorists attacks in the first
place
★
That both side needs to
refrain from exercising violence, not only the Palestinians, but
also Israelis themselves
The Palestinian
side
●
The Palestinians have to recognise that the Jewish state
will be there and forever and accept this as a fait accompli. To
expel the Israelis and restore sovereignty over the so-called
historic territory owned by Palestinians is completely
impossible.
●
Further, the Palestinians
should understand that they have to accept a deal in which they
would preserve only 20% of their historic land, even in the
circumstances that Israeli ends its occupation in West Bank and
Gaza Strip.
●
The Palestinians’ assertion
that refugees, the Palestinian Exodus, after 1948, should have the
right to return to Israel, is impossible. It is a myth that thwarts
negotiation of the two sides. Millions of refugees, were they to
return, would render Israel losing its Jewish demographic majority,
and a Jewish majority is one of the most important principle that
Jewish people would maintain.
●
It is probably true that full and complete
withdrawal of settlements in the occupied West Bank (involving
hundreds of thousands Jewish settlers after 1967) by the Israelis
is unrealistic and the Palestinians should accept the fact that
several biggest blocks of settlements are to remain there
permanently as a fait accompli. However, the conflict of territory
claims should be solved by land swap, i.e. a redrawing of border
line, in which Israeli should hand over lands (of its own in
Pre-1967 territory) equivalent to its occupation in West Bank in
terms of size of area, as a fair deal, and the Palestinian should
accept the deal if it is perceived sufficiently
fair.
Both side should acknowledge the fact that if
they do not sit down to negotiate based on these understandings
there would be no peace but permanent conflict and
violence.